Craft Yarn Council of America Home | Learn To Knit & Crochet Home | BACK

Advertising or commercial messages are not allowed on the forums.

Posters to these boards are knitters and crocheters like yourself. If you have a specific question for the Craft Yarn Council, please send an email message to:

To get the most out of these boards, before posting a topic, we suggest:

Scrolling through past posts to see if your question has already been asked and answered. Postings are in chronological order of the date when the topic was first posted. You can also use the SEARCH function to look for past posts about your question.

If you don't see your question addressed, or if you have additional questions, post a New Topic rather than replying to an existing topic. This will increase the likelihood of getting responses to your specific question. Also, try to describe your specific question in the topic subject line rather than "New Knitter" or "Help."

The more information you can provide in your question, the better the responses.

We hope you enjoy the postings on this board and will come back to share your knowledge with others.

Forums > Knitting
Re: Best - Cast-On way - for a tight 1st row ??
Posted by: Alex (IP Logged)
Date: October 14, 2008 04:21PM

I like alternating cable for 1x1 rib Unlike simple cable (which is quite attractive, but also, as KT says, quite firm) it has a lot of give. It is also almost as invisible as tubular. That is, the knit and purl stitches look as though they were knit and purled all the way from the edge.

I have samples of many different cast-ons which I have made for my classes and of the most popular, the sample that stretches the most at the bottom of plain stockinette (no ribbing) is backward loop. It also rolls up almost twice as much as long-tail and considerably more than simple knit-on. Simple knit-on holds its shape less than either long-tail or cable but more than backward loop. Long-tail done on the same needles as the rest of the work draws the work in tremendously Another sample was worked very loosely on the same-size needles and looks very sloppy and uneven. The sample worked on needles two sizes larger looks very good and tends to curl up a little less. The simple cable curls up the least.

I'd try cable if I were you. The crochet co has no give at all and cable might be a good middle of the road choice because it does have some give. If you do decide to use it, use the same size needles as you will for the rest of the fabric.

When I'm teaching beginners I always teach knit-on because the students are learning to knit as they learn to cast-on. It's then a very simple step to cable and alternating cable.

Subject Written By Posted
  Best - Cast-On way - for a tight 1st row ?? Mother Hen 10/14/2008 09:47AM
  Re: Best - Cast-On way - for a tight 1st row ?? Sally J 10/14/2008 12:02PM
  Re: Best - Cast-On way - for a tight 1st row ?? KT 10/14/2008 12:13PM
  Re: Best - Cast-On way - for a tight 1st row ?? Alex 10/14/2008 04:21PM
  Re: Best - Cast-On way - for a tight 1st row ?? Mrs. K 10/18/2008 11:42PM

This is the old forum archive. If you have new questions please post in the new forum.

©2007 Craft Yarn Council of America